While distribution of narcotics is a serious felony with a 20-year maximum jail sentence, prosecutors were not satisfied that this charge fully accounted for the defendant’s conduct. The State’s Attorney sought additional charges of manslaughter and reckless endangerment to incorporate criminal responsibility for the defendant in the death of the 50 year-old man. A grand jury agreed and returned an indictment for these two counts plus the original two drug counts. No plea agreement was reached, and the defendant gave up his right to a jury trial in favor of bench trial the Snow Hill Circuit Court. It didn’t take long for the judge to find the defendant guilty on all counts, and now he awaits sentencing in July. In addition to the 20-year max for distribution, the defendant also faces a 10-year sentence for manslaughter, 5 years for reckless endangerment and 4 years for possession. The defendant has multiple prior convictions for assault, which the judge will surely take into account at the sentencing hearing.
Charging an alleged drug dealer for manslaughter when a buyer overdoses is not a new concept nationwide or in Maryland, but that is not to say it is a common practice. Some states have specific statutes that enhance drug crimes when a buyer is injured or dies, but it is still rare to see a manslaughter conviction in a drug case. In this case though, police and prosecutors had ample evidence (most provided by the defendant himself) that the defendant directly supplied the heroin to the deceased and that he remained with the deceased while he took the deadly dose. To sustain a conviction for manslaughter in Maryland the state must prove the defendant committed an unlawful act that killed someone during the course of that act. The cell phone evidence gathered by police combined with the statements all but sealed the defendant’s fate.
Despite the fact that manslaughter has a lower maximum sentence than drug distribution, law enforcement hopes that cases like this get a strong message out to potential dealers. The average citizen would probably be surprised to learn that manslaughter carries a lower sentence than distribution, but manslaughter sounds like a far more serious crime. When you are trying to send a message the public perception is simply more important than the legalese.
Benjamin Herbst is a Worcester County criminal defense attorney who handles cases from Ocean City and all other Eastern Shore locations. Benjamin specializes in drug crimes and felony offenses such as manslaughter, and is available for a free consultation anytime.
Resources
Heroin Dealer Convicted Of Manslaughter After Berlin Man’s Overdose Death, mdcoastdispatch.com.